WSM vs. ProQ Excel 20...the results are in...

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Great videos. While I'm not about to get rid of my WSM, it looks like the ProQ would be a good choice as well.
 
Stogie said:
Thanks for taking the time to do this.

Unfortunately, don't have time to sit thru 20 minutes of video!

Is it possible to recap in a couple of sentences?

If so, thanks!

Even though it was called a tie, if you read between the lines here the tester (Smokey J's?) definitely had a preference for the WSM. Reasons: tighter fit, better quality of materials, outside metal stays cool & cheaper price. Only con really was the water pan which most people get the Brinkman charcoal pan as a cheap mod.

Pro Q: Pros: More capacity, has handles on the side, eyelts for temp, bigger water pan, probe, place for a thermometer.
Cons: Did not feel as sturdy when assembled. Very hot to the touch. Handle on lid top not very good quality. Requires side latches to properly seal. Access door very hot and requires gloves to open.

At least that was my quick read of the video which BTW was great. Good job guys on trying to keep everything even in the contest.

Winner by decision, the current and future champ: WSM!

Hopefully the WSM will adapt some of the nice mods that the Pro Q put in.
Competition is good for consumers!
 
Back
Top Bottom