Old Dave's Stew, Tavern Stew, 5 Hour Stew

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Old Dave

Senior Cook
Joined
Mar 29, 2009
Messages
271
Location
Indiana
I have used this old recipe for over 50 years and it is the best stew recipe I have ever tasted. It is easy to make and can be changed to suit about anyones taste.

img_259800_0_be4feb948abaffce229d998e176bf114.jpg


It calls for beef stew meat and I always cut my own so I like to use a thick chuck roast for my meat.

img_259800_1_1fbc20426a0c9c86563643243db1779e.jpg


A fellow can cut it up into the size he wants and in my case, about 1-1/4 to 1-1/2 “ squares.

img_259800_2_9256c7e69b716d4c7628ff59923cf808.jpg


Then I get some celery, carrots, green bell pepper, onions, potatoes, and hot peppers all processed for my stew. You can leave out the peppers if you don’t like the hotter stew.

img_259800_3_2380e2bce520f3d46f656b7f47b9b862.jpg


All of the above is placed into a large Dutch oven for the cook.

img_259800_4_1de500a5a1eedf86e8104da767927d63.jpg


I then add my spices and juice over the mixture and it is ready for the oven.

img_259800_5_e6292e565bd448b4c63a191dc692c28e.jpg


Put the lid on and place it into a 250 degree oven for about 5 hours.

img_259800_6_0ee02f88fff1f6ef72ad978c1134c70c.jpg


img_259800_7_c12599d248a9ac4e408b5efc1365643f.jpg


Looking good coming out of the oven.

img_259800_8_82bb7e4e26bc1aca7e088002b2478571.jpg


img_259800_9_bf07c5dc09ced94591e221a87d5cf4cc.jpg


As served...

Ok, here is the basic recipe and the method of doing this stew.

2 lbs beef stew meat
4-6 carrots sliced or chopped
4-6 potatoes cut into quarters or smaller
1 cup sliced celery
1 green bell pepper diced
1 or 2 medium onions chopped

Combine all of the above in a Dutch oven and for the hotter version be sure to include the hot peppers.

The next step and be sure to follow these directions.

3 TBL tapioca
1-1/2 tsp salt
1 tsp black pepper
1 TBL sugar

Sprinkle these items over the top of the stew but DO NOT MIX.

Pour in 12 oz or if you like more juice use 24 oz of V8 vegetable juice over the mixture but again, DO NOT MIX.

Cover and bake in a 250 degree oven for 5 hours and again DO NOT MIX or even raise the lid on the Dutch oven until its done.

Now, here are some of the things I do different from the basic recipe.

I usually always make a double batch.
I usually add some extra meat in my stew
I usually use some hot peppers in my stew.
I like more celery and green bell pepper in mine so I add that.
I use the hot V8 juice and usually about 48 oz in my larger batches

I usually bake mine at about 275 degrees and for about 6 hours to get my larger amount done.

Anyway, make it with what you like but do be sure to follow the basic directions.
 
I love chuck roast, this looks like a good meal on a cold winter night!
 
I would like to try making this recipe, it looks great! Unfortunately, I don't think i can. I can't not stir it, I will freak out.
 
Buzz,

I am the last fellow to ask about a good beer for anything. I do love the stuff but really don't appreciate the better products. Heck, I drink that Milwaukee's Best Light and think it is fine beer so you can see how twisted I am with the beer.

Dave
 
I've never had this stew, but I'm an avid homebrewer and a beer fan, can I chime in on this one? Beef stew is good with an american brown ale like Big Sky Moose Drool, or english pub ale, maybe some of that Old Speckled Hen. Or waulkees, the first three aren't so good, but keep at it, they get better!
 
I've never had this stew, but I'm an avid homebrewer and a beer fan, can I chime in on this one? Beef stew is good with an american brown ale like Big Sky Moose Drool, or english pub ale, maybe some of that Old Speckled Hen. Or waulkees, the first three aren't so good, but keep at it, they get better!

Thanks for the suggestions Boozer have had Old Speckled Hen and liked that, might try to find some Old Mil Light to honor Old Dave when I make the stew. My philosophy on beer is "all beer is good some is just better than others" (can't drink Miller Lite though). ;)
 
Have this one in the oven right now, but did not find OML so will pair with "Hamms Special Light" and then maybe chase that with a North Peak Diabolical. Thanks for what looks to be a great dinner suggestion Dave!
 
Aint seen any Topioca since old Shep was still just a pup and my best friend's old maid aunt used it for making pudding. Can a person sub out something for that?
 
We buy some things as WW but not many groceries. Mostly panty hose and hedge clippers and stuff like that. They also have cheap sugar but aint needed none lately. Too hot to get a good ferment going for ho made wine.
 
My philosophy on beer is "all beer is good some is just better than others" ;)
I agree 100%. I'm not a "beer snob" by any means, but sometimes it's worth spending a little more for a really great beer, especially paired with a really great meal!
 
I agree 100%. I'm not a "beer snob" by any means, but sometimes it's worth spending a little more for a really great beer, especially paired with a really great meal!

I have to agree day in and day out regular beer is fine but I do appreciate "Good" once or twice a week. I did by chance have a couple of Big Sky Moose Drool you mentioned, nice beer.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom