Thanks for the advice, I pretty much of knew which was the better grill, but still valued any input from this great resource. I just happened to walk by a Magnum in the store while purchasing an unrelated product and paused for a moment to check it out. As the weather gets nicer here in MN, should I look for a garage sale Weber, kind of like the barn car find, or just get a new one? Thanks for the help!!!!!!!!!!!
By the way I own a Weber Silver gas grill (check out the "I had to have wings" post from earlier) that I love.